Scribbled in the margin: "off the record" information
April 11, 2009 at 5:25 pm | Posted in Ramblings, Seen and Scene | Leave a commentTags: journalism, journalism ethics, notes, off the record, rapport, reporter, source
If there’s one thing journalists hate hearing from their sources it’s the dreaded “this is off the record,” as if that in itself makes the source immune to attacks, questions and criticisms. Some people may think “off the record” comments make the information useless. Not quite. Usually this information at least provides better perspective for the reporter so there’s less chance of misconstruing the words of the source. So not all off the record information is completely useless.
But today, during a casual chat with the manager of an e-waste recycling company, my source followed up half his sentences with “off the record.” I soon found it a waste of energy even picking up my pen to take notes, since almost all of his information was off the record. (I make it a point to literally set my pen down when any source says ‘off the record,’ as an indication and reassurance that yes, “This information is safe with me.”)
However, in response to one of my questions today, the source said, “Well the press never depicts anything realistically anyway, so just say such-and-such.” And that’s when I had to speak up.
Well, well mister, maybe if we were able to “record” more of the things you said, it would be possible to present a clearer picture of what the situation is. It’s kind of hard to report something accurately when sources keep insisting the information is “off the record.”
As careful as a person may want to be with regard to the media, and as skeptical they may be of the media’s intentions, sometimes, being overly caustious and hiding behind the “off the record” wall could potentially create more problems for the source him/herself if you ask me. Sure, sources don’t want to get in trouble from the authorities or be misrepresented, but if they refuse to let an entire chunk of information be presented to the public, chances are high that they’re still not going to be satisfied with what the press publishes.
Lawyers get a bad rep for being liars, business execs for being ruthless, and journalists, well, for not being accurate (sadly). Forgetting the sleazy journalists who only care about sensationalism and an easy buck–sources, the less information you give us, the harder it is for us to paint an accurate picture.
Scribbled in the margin: conversation with a Fulbright Fellow
March 29, 2009 at 3:34 pm | Posted in At work | 1 CommentTags: diplomacy, Fulbright Fellowship, Fulbright-Nehru Fellowship, internship diary, notes
I spoke to four Fulbright Fellows yesterday at a press conference held by the U.S. Consul General announcing the 2010 Fulbright-Nehru Fellowships, aimed a scholarly exchange between India and the U.S. specifically.
I was most interested in what Shiva Ayyadurai of M.I.T. had to say, because his personal experience coming back to India for professional reasons reminded me so much of my own: he was born in India, but lived in India only until the age of 7, and then moved to the U.S. So he essentially had grown up in the U.S., but he never forgot the traditional healing techniques used by his grandmother back in their village to treat neighbors. He studied modern systems biology in the U.S., which he explained is the “West’s attempt to understand the entire body from a molecular basis.” But remembering the Indian traditional healing methods back home, he applied for the Fellowship to study Siddha Yoga and the links between yogic remedies and Western medicine.
Til now, he said the West’s understanding of yoga is not even a tenth of the knowledge that is actually available in India. The Indian system of “guna” really does have implications in Western medicine. He explained that Indian medicine is so closely tied with spirituality and happiness, but there are chemicals released during these “happy” and healthy states. By figuring out the molecular break-down of those chemicals (which he says he’s pretty much identified), he can relate it to Western medicine and treatments.
Amazing.
The icing on the cake: this would be one solution to the health care crisis in the U.S. Citing R&D costs that have already been increasing 20-30 percent yearly since 1996, he said the government is setting aside a decent sum to explore alternative medicine (most attention goes to Chinese healing techniques). He suggested that natural treatment through yogic medicine could quite possibly be the solution to battling the high prices at which drugs are sold by U.S.-based pharmaceutical companies: “The molecular age can meet the yogic age.”
Plus, it was also nice to hear, on a personal note, of his experience coming back to India. After awhile you get used to the fact activities which used to be routine in the States are more labor-intensive and time consuming in India. To be honest, I feel the same way. After being here for more than three months now, I definitely see how we’re somewhat spoiled in the U.S.
As he put it, “In the West we talk a lot about sustainability. In some ways, people here [India] live sustainability already.”
When Shiva first got here, he couldn’t stand the heat or the “1-bucket” system of bathing, etc. Now, he says, he can definitely picture himself settling down here.
Scribbled in the margin
March 29, 2009 at 3:33 pm | Posted in At work | Leave a commentTags: internship diary, journalism, notes
I have the best job in the world because I get an education free of cost. Scratch that– I get paid to learn something new everyday.
But because they say you don’t even use 90% of the notes you take, often, when you come back to the office to write a story, there are so many things that you have to leave out because they’re not relevant to the story you’re writing. Still, when I hear someone make a good point, I can’t help but scribble it in the margin, because I feel it’s something I want to share with friends or it’s a lesson I can put to use in my own life. So this is my way of sharing whatever didn’t make the cut of being included in my published stories.
Blog at WordPress.com. | Theme: Pool by Borja Fernandez.
Entries and comments feeds.





